Fan Debate: Adapting Giant Characters, Haki, and CP9 in Live Action
Recent fan discussions on the r/OnePieceLiveAction subreddit focus on how future live-action episodes should translate distinct manga elements. Posters have proposed specific solutions for depicting towering characters like Kuma, introducing CP9's Six Powers during the Water 7 Arc, preserving Sniper King's signature look, and interpreting the meaning of the word Haki, while also ranking Devil Fruits seen in Seasons 1 and 2.
Towering Statures and Iconic Designs
As fans look ahead to future storylines, a major talking point on r/OnePieceLiveAction is how the show will visually represent characters with exaggerated manga proportions. In an October 26, 2026 post, one fan argued that while not every tall manga character needs to keep their massive size in live action, it is essential for certain figures like Kuma. The poster suggested that the production should look to how Hagrid was filmed in the Harry Potter movies as the best solution for handling characters of enormous stature.
Smaller character design details are also sparking discussion. In an October 24, 2026 thread, another Reddit user expressed hope that if the live-action series reaches that point in the story, the production will keep the long nose on Sniper King's mask rather than giving the character a short-nosed design.
Translating CP9's Six Powers and Haki for Live-Action Viewers
Beyond character appearances, community members are debating how to adapt complex combat systems and terminology for viewers who have not read the manga or watched the anime. In an October 14, 2026 post regarding a potential adaptation of the Water 7 Arc, a fan suggested that introducing all of CP9's Six Powers in a single scene, as done with Blueno in the source material, would be a hassle in live action. Instead, the poster proposed that non-anime viewers would have an easier time following the abilities if each power were limited to one at a time.
Language translation is another area of debate. An October 15, 2026 post on r/OnePieceLiveAction pointed out that the word "haki" is not a unique fantasy term invented by Eiichiro Oda, but an ordinary Japanese word meaning "ambition" or "drive." Because Japanese readers naturally interpret the concept as someone's ambition becoming strong enough to manifest, fans are discussing how that context carries over to international audiences.
Comparing Devil Fruits from Seasons 1 and 2
Alongside debates about future arcs, fans continue to discuss the powers already established in the first two seasons. In a November 7, 2026 thread asking readers which ability they would choose using only Season 1 and Season 2 knowledge, a poster ranked eight Devil Fruits from least wanted to most wanted: Chopper's Human-Human Fruit, Alvida's Slip-Slip Fruit, Miss Valentine's Kilo-Kilo Fruit, Dalton's Ox-Ox Fruit (Model: Bison), Mr. 5's Bomb-Bomb Fruit, Buggy's Chop-Chop Fruit, Luffy's Gum-Gum Fruit, and Miss All Sunday's Flower-Flower Fruit.
Two sides of the debate
Preserve Signature Manga Traits
- Enormous stature is essential for specific characters like Kuma and can be achieved using filming techniques similar to Hagrid in the Harry Potter films.
- Iconic visual gags and designs, such as keeping the long nose on Sniper King, should not be removed if the show reaches those arcs.
Adjust Elements for Live-Action Pacing and Clarity
- Not every manga character with an exaggerated stature necessarily needs to retain that massive height in the live-action adaptation.
- Introducing all of CP9's Six Powers in a single scene with Blueno would be a hassle, so limiting how those powers are presented would help non-anime viewers.
- Terms like "haki" are ordinary words meaning "ambition" or "drive" in Japanese, meaning the concept relies on linguistic context that is not automatically obvious to non-Japanese audiences.
Your turn
How does this make you feel?
Poll: How should the live-action series handle CP9's Six Powers and giant characters?
Vote to see what other fans think.
Which manga designs or power systems do you think need to be adjusted for live-action viewers, and which ones must stay exactly the same?
- Loading opinions…
Sources
We summarise in our own words. Read the originals:
- The way they did Hagrid in the HP films is the best solution for OPLA to deal with characters of enormous stature · r/OnePieceLiveAction · Oct 26, 2026 · Fan discussion
- Something i HOPE they don’t do · r/OnePieceLiveAction · Oct 24, 2026 · Fan discussion
- Hear me out (explanation inside) · r/OnePieceLiveAction · Oct 15, 2026 · Fan discussion
- Opinion about the handling of “CP9” (spoiler) · r/OnePieceLiveAction · Oct 14, 2026 · Fan discussion
- If you could have One Devil Fruit from the users we've seen so far whose would you Pick? (Try not to Spoil anything, Please Season 1-2 knowledge only) · r/OnePieceLiveAction · Nov 7, 2026 · Fan discussion
